PureXML/Sources/Schema/SimpleType.swift
Mihaela Mihaljevic 4bd23d8286 feat(schema): built-in xsi:type resolution gated by substitution validity
Resolve a built-in datatype named by xsi:type (xsd:int, xsd:decimal,
xsd:string), which previously resolved only against schema-declared types and
so reported "unknown" and wrongly rejected the element. The built-in is now
resolved when it validly substitutes for the declared type per Schema-Validity
Assessment: the ur-type (anyType/anySimpleType) admits any type, and a bare
built-in declared type admits any built-in derived from it through the XSD
Part 2 datatype lattice (new BuiltinType.derives(from:)). An invalid built-in
substitution is a located error, not a silent acceptance.

Resolving the override correctly exposed two pre-existing gaps, both closed so
the change carries no invalid-instances-accepted regression:

- A simple-typed element rejects non-schema-instance attributes. A simple type
  declares no attribute uses, so an element of simple type (including via an
  xsi:type override, and including an xsi:nil element) may carry only xsi:* and
  namespace attributes. Checked before the nil short-circuit.
- Identity-constraint fields compare in their value space when the selected
  node carries an xsi:type. unique/key/keyref tuples compared lexically, so two
  xsi:type="xsd:decimal" fields 3.0 and 3 were treated as distinct and a unique
  violation was missed. Each field value now carries the type read from the
  node's xsi:type and compares via SimpleType.valueMatches when both share a
  built-in base, otherwise lexically.

XSTS: valid instances rejected 248 to 233; invalid instances accepted held at
165. Identity tests corrected to spec-valid schemas (an element carrying an
attribute must be a complex type, not type="xs:string").
2026-06-13 21:21:35 +02:00

305 lines
15 KiB
Swift

public extension PureXML.Schema {
/// The constraining facets of a simple type. Every facet is optional; an unset
/// facet imposes no constraint. `patterns` are combined with AND.
struct Facets: Sendable {
public var length: Int?
public var minLength: Int?
public var maxLength: Int?
public var patterns: [String]
public var enumeration: [String]?
public var whiteSpace: WhiteSpace?
public var minInclusive: String?
public var maxInclusive: String?
public var minExclusive: String?
public var maxExclusive: String?
public var totalDigits: Int?
public var fractionDigits: Int?
public init(
length: Int? = nil,
minLength: Int? = nil,
maxLength: Int? = nil,
patterns: [String] = [],
enumeration: [String]? = nil,
whiteSpace: WhiteSpace? = nil,
minInclusive: String? = nil,
maxInclusive: String? = nil,
minExclusive: String? = nil,
maxExclusive: String? = nil,
totalDigits: Int? = nil,
fractionDigits: Int? = nil,
) {
self.length = length
self.minLength = minLength
self.maxLength = maxLength
self.patterns = patterns
self.enumeration = enumeration
self.whiteSpace = whiteSpace
self.minInclusive = minInclusive
self.maxInclusive = maxInclusive
self.minExclusive = minExclusive
self.maxExclusive = maxExclusive
self.totalDigits = totalDigits
self.fractionDigits = fractionDigits
}
/// Whether no facet narrows the base type's value space: the type is the
/// bare built-in. Used to decide whether an `xsi:type` built-in may validly
/// substitute for a declared type (a faceted restriction may not be the
/// target of a built-in substitution).
public var isUnconstrained: Bool {
length == nil && minLength == nil && maxLength == nil && patterns.isEmpty
&& enumeration == nil && whiteSpace == nil
&& minInclusive == nil && maxInclusive == nil
&& minExclusive == nil && maxExclusive == nil
&& totalDigits == nil && fractionDigits == nil
}
}
/// A simple type's variety (XSD Part 2): atomic, a whitespace-separated list
/// of an item type, or a union of member types.
indirect enum Variety: Sendable {
case atomic
case list(SimpleType)
case union([SimpleType])
}
/// A simple type: a built-in base restricted by facets, of one of the three
/// varieties. Validates a lexical value against the XSD Part 2 rules:
/// whitespace processing, the base value space, the base's intrinsic bounds,
/// then the facets. A list checks each item against the item type and counts
/// items for the length facets; a union admits a value valid for any member.
struct SimpleType: Sendable {
public var base: BuiltinType
public var facets: Facets
public var variety: Variety
public init(base: BuiltinType, facets: Facets = Facets(), variety: Variety = .atomic) {
self.base = base
self.facets = facets
self.variety = variety
}
/// A list type whose items are `item`, carrying its own (list) facets.
public static func list(item: SimpleType, facets: Facets = Facets()) -> SimpleType {
SimpleType(base: .string, facets: facets, variety: .list(item))
}
/// A union of `members`: a value is valid if any member admits it.
public static func union(_ members: [SimpleType]) -> SimpleType {
SimpleType(base: .string, variety: .union(members))
}
/// Whether `lexical` is a valid value of this type.
public func isValid(_ lexical: String) -> Bool {
validate(lexical) == nil
}
/// A description of the first constraint `lexical` violates, or nil when it
/// is valid.
public func validate(_ lexical: String) -> String? {
switch variety {
case .atomic: validateAtomic(lexical)
case let .list(item): validateList(lexical, item: item)
case let .union(members): validateUnion(lexical, members: members)
}
}
private func validateList(_ lexical: String, item: SimpleType) -> String? {
let normalized = Self.process(lexical, whiteSpace: facets.whiteSpace ?? .collapse)
let tokens = normalized.isEmpty ? [] : normalized.split(separator: " ").map(String.init)
for token in tokens {
if let error = item.validate(token) { return error }
}
if let exact = facets.length, tokens.count != exact { return "list length \(tokens.count) is not \(exact)" }
if let minimum = facets.minLength, tokens.count < minimum { return "list length \(tokens.count) is below \(minimum)" }
if let maximum = facets.maxLength, tokens.count > maximum { return "list length \(tokens.count) is above \(maximum)" }
if let error = patternError(normalized) { return error }
if let enumeration = facets.enumeration, !enumeration.contains(normalized) {
return "'\(normalized)' is not in the enumeration"
}
return nil
}
/// Whether `instance` and `literal` denote the same value in this type's
/// value space, the comparison a RELAX NG `<value>` performs. Ordered
/// types (numeric, date/time) compare in value space, so `1` equals `01`
/// and `1.0` equals `1.00`; booleans treat `1`/`true` and `0`/`false` as
/// equal. Every other type, including `string`/`token`, compares by its
/// whitespace-normalized lexical form. (Durations and binary types fall
/// under the lexical rule, so only their normalized forms compare equal.)
public func valueMatches(_ instance: String, literal: String) -> Bool {
let whiteSpace = facets.whiteSpace ?? base.whiteSpace
let left = Self.process(instance, whiteSpace: whiteSpace)
let right = Self.process(literal, whiteSpace: whiteSpace)
switch base.primitive {
case .decimal, .integer, .double, .float, .dateKind:
guard let leftValue = base.primitive.ordered(left), let rightValue = base.primitive.ordered(right) else { return false }
return leftValue == rightValue
case .boolean:
guard let leftValue = Self.booleanValue(left) else { return false }
return leftValue == Self.booleanValue(right)
default:
return left == right
}
}
private static func booleanValue(_ value: String) -> Bool? {
switch value {
case "true", "1": true
case "false", "0": false
default: nil
}
}
private func validateUnion(_ lexical: String, members: [SimpleType]) -> String? {
// The value must be valid against at least one member type.
guard members.contains(where: { $0.validate(lexical) == nil }) else {
return "'\(lexical)' does not match any member type of the union"
}
// `pattern` and `enumeration` are the only constraining facets XSD
// allows on a union (Datatypes 4.1.5); both apply on top of membership.
// Pattern matches the lexical value; enumeration compares in the
// value space of whichever member admits each value, so `01` equals an
// enumerated `1` for an integer member, matching the atomic path.
if let error = patternError(lexical) { return error }
if let enumeration = facets.enumeration {
let inEnumeration = enumeration.contains { candidate in
members.contains { $0.valueMatches(lexical, literal: candidate) }
}
if !inEnumeration { return "'\(lexical)' is not in the enumeration" }
}
return nil
}
private func validateAtomic(_ lexical: String) -> String? {
let value = Self.process(lexical, whiteSpace: facets.whiteSpace ?? base.whiteSpace)
let primitive = base.primitive
guard primitive.isValid(value) else {
return "'\(lexical)' is not a valid \(base.rawValue)"
}
return boundsError(value, primitive)
?? lengthError(value, primitive)
?? digitsError(value)
?? patternError(value)
?? enumerationError(value, primitive)
?? rangeError(value, primitive)
}
// MARK: Whitespace
static func process(_ value: String, whiteSpace: WhiteSpace) -> String {
switch whiteSpace {
case .preserve:
return value
case .replace:
return String(value.map { ($0 == "\t" || $0 == "\n" || $0 == "\r") ? " " : $0 })
case .collapse:
let replaced = value.map { ($0 == "\t" || $0 == "\n" || $0 == "\r") ? " " : $0 }
return String(replaced).split(separator: " ").joined(separator: " ")
}
}
// MARK: Facet checks
private func boundsError(_ value: String, _: Primitive) -> String? {
let (lower, upper) = base.bounds
guard lower != nil || upper != nil, let decimal = DecimalValue(value, allowFraction: false) else {
return nil
}
if let lower, decimal < lower { return "\(value) is below the minimum for \(base.rawValue)" }
if let upper, decimal > upper { return "\(value) is above the maximum for \(base.rawValue)" }
return nil
}
private func lengthError(_ value: String, _ primitive: Primitive) -> String? {
// length/minLength/maxLength measure characters, octets, or list
// items depending on the type; for QName the spec leaves the unit
// unspecified (XSD 1.0 Datatypes 4.3.1), so like Xerces and the XSTS
// NIST oracle we do not constrain QName values by length.
if case .qName = primitive { return nil }
let length = primitive.measuredLength(value)
if let exact = facets.length, length != exact { return "length \(length) is not \(exact)" }
if let minimum = facets.minLength, length < minimum { return "length \(length) is below \(minimum)" }
if let maximum = facets.maxLength, length > maximum { return "length \(length) is above \(maximum)" }
return nil
}
private func digitsError(_ value: String) -> String? {
guard facets.totalDigits != nil || facets.fractionDigits != nil,
let decimal = DecimalValue(value, allowFraction: true) else { return nil }
if let total = facets.totalDigits, decimal.totalDigits > total { return "more than \(total) total digits" }
if let fraction = facets.fractionDigits, decimal.fractionDigits.count > fraction {
return "more than \(fraction) fraction digits"
}
return nil
}
private func patternError(_ value: String) -> String? {
for pattern in facets.patterns {
guard let regex = try? PureXML.Regex.Pattern(pattern), regex.matches(value) else {
return "'\(value)' does not match pattern '\(pattern)'"
}
}
return nil
}
private func enumerationError(_ value: String, _ primitive: Primitive) -> String? {
guard let enumeration = facets.enumeration else { return nil }
let whiteSpace = facets.whiteSpace ?? base.whiteSpace
let matched = enumeration.contains { candidate in
let normalized = Self.process(candidate, whiteSpace: whiteSpace)
if let lhs = primitive.ordered(value), let rhs = primitive.ordered(normalized) { return lhs == rhs }
return normalized == value
}
return matched ? nil : "'\(value)' is not in the enumeration"
}
private func rangeError(_ value: String, _ primitive: Primitive) -> String? {
if case .duration = primitive { return durationRangeError(value) }
guard let actual = primitive.ordered(value) else { return nil }
if let bound = facets.minInclusive, let limit = primitive.ordered(bound), actual < limit {
return "\(value) is below the inclusive minimum"
}
if let bound = facets.maxInclusive, let limit = primitive.ordered(bound), actual > limit {
return "\(value) is above the inclusive maximum"
}
if let bound = facets.minExclusive, let limit = primitive.ordered(bound), !(limit < actual) {
return "\(value) is not above the exclusive minimum"
}
if let bound = facets.maxExclusive, let limit = primitive.ordered(bound), !(actual < limit) {
return "\(value) is not below the exclusive maximum"
}
return nil
}
/// Ordering facets on `xs:duration`, which is a partial order: a value
/// that is incomparable to the bound does not satisfy it (it is not in
/// the ordered range), so an incomparable result is a violation.
private func durationRangeError(_ value: String) -> String? {
guard let actual = DurationValue(value) else { return nil }
func order(_ bound: String?) -> DurationOrder? {
bound.flatMap(DurationValue.init).map(actual.compare(to:))
}
if let order = order(facets.minInclusive), order == .lessThan || order == .incomparable {
return "\(value) is below the inclusive minimum"
}
if let order = order(facets.maxInclusive), order == .greaterThan || order == .incomparable {
return "\(value) is above the inclusive maximum"
}
if let order = order(facets.minExclusive), order != .greaterThan {
return "\(value) is not above the exclusive minimum"
}
if let order = order(facets.maxExclusive), order != .lessThan {
return "\(value) is not below the exclusive maximum"
}
return nil
}
}
/// Validates `value` against a built-in type with no extra facets.
static func isValid(_ value: String, type: BuiltinType) -> Bool {
SimpleType(base: type).isValid(value)
}
}